Celebrating 10 years! 2007-2017

Using a Legal Search Firm/Recruiter?

I'm a 4th year attorney trying to lateral from a small firm muaddib08/24/16
I work in estate planning and probate law. It's very niche a tulip08/26/16
Wow, interesting insight. I'm also in a niche area--land us muaddib08/31/16
Where? I am a senior associate in a mid law land use group. retard05/11/17
which geographic location? I might be able to help you out dingbat05/12/17
When it comes to shadiness, your instincts are generally rig loser1208/27/16
My first question is what market are you looking in? Even th smishsmash08/30/16
not OP but if you have an recs for NYC I'd love to hear them bingojackson08/30/16
I'm looking in LA and it seems like the market is just super muaddib08/31/16
while I think there's some value in being persistent and eve bingojackson09/01/16
Uhg. I was expecting three months... Time to buckle up I gue muaddib09/01/16
Although I'm sure there are several reasons why jobs don't o pauperesq09/01/16
muaddib (Aug 24, 2016 - 9:03 pm)

I'm a 4th year attorney trying to lateral from a small firm into mid-law. I've been searching for almost two months (and had several interviews) but decided to start using a recruiter.

Over the past few weeks, I've had wildly different (and sometimes, strangely unpleasant) interactions with several different search firms/recruiters.

Does anyone have any:

(1) opinions on the general usefulness of a search firm/recruiter;
(2) recommendations for a good search firm/recruiter;
(3) insight re reputation of BCG attorney search, Swan Legal, Lateral Link, or any other search firms?

Reply
tulip (Aug 26, 2016 - 9:20 pm)

I work in estate planning and probate law. It's very niche and therefore difficult to find a job so I've tried recruiters. I've used Robert Half and 2 small local companies. Robert Half was awful, the people I met with were nice and knowledgeable but they never followed up. Never gave me leads. After discussing my job goals in depth, I got 1 call from someone at Robert Half asking if I would like to interview for a doc review job (no). I also get emails from them about job hunting or potential leads that have nothing to do with law or my skill set. And on top of it, they don't validate parking! The two smaller local recruiters worked well, one really knew the estate planning market, revised my resume, did mock interview with me and set me up on a few interviews. The other local recruiter was also super thorough and sent me on interviews. She helped me compare the firm's that I was offered positions with and helped me decide. And the firm's we were comparing were 2 that she didn't even arrange for me.

I would recommend using local recruiters but constantly check in with them so you are fresh in their mind. Also, keep looking yourself don't rely only on a recruiter.

Don't use BCG, terrible reviews and totally shady.

Reply
muaddib (Aug 31, 2016 - 6:06 pm)

Wow, interesting insight. I'm also in a niche area--land use & environmental litigation--and I had a similar experience with Lateral Link. After I talked to them about my goals, they kept sending me doc review positions (or staff attorney nonsense). Most recently they tried to get me to submit for a "e-discovery specialist" position in another city that would've been a 30% pay cut... I don't know what recruiters like this are thinking...

I also instinctively thought that using a local recruiter would be more fruitful, but I've had a pretty negative experience with them so far. They generally seem to have fewer recruiters, and thus are very focused on finding "glossy" candidates so that the recruiter doesn't have to work too hard to get them positions.

Reply
retard (May 11, 2017 - 7:24 pm)

Where? I am a senior associate in a mid law land use group. Openings are rare at the associate level, very few associate candidates are even qualified to get an interview. It's a very partner heavy practice area.

Reply
dingbat (May 12, 2017 - 9:27 am)

which geographic location?
I might be able to help you out

Reply
loser12 (Aug 27, 2016 - 3:46 pm)

When it comes to shadiness, your instincts are generally right. BCG is also shady. You wind up getting spam email because they add you to like 30 email lists after you reply to them. It reminded me of craigslist scams from back in the day.

Reply
smishsmash (Aug 30, 2016 - 12:22 pm)

My first question is what market are you looking in? Even the national recruiting companies vary greatly from market to market.

IMO, a good recruiter needs to not only be knowledgable, but persistent without being aggressive. And, a while a recruiter always has some sort of value if they have relationships at firms with the hiring parter(s) or head or HR, they have the most value when they can bring you unposted positions.

An underrated value a good recruiter can provide is prepping you for the interviews and providing background on the partners you'll interview with. While a lot of people may think they either know what they're doing or can handle an interview, in my experience, there are very specific answers most of these firms want from their potential lateral associate hires. If your recruiter is a good one, he can help you with your answers by roleplaying the right questions.

With all that being said, this time of year specifically positions don't come up often (which is one of two reasons why you may not be getting the follow up you want). The other reason, may be your not an attractive candidate for mid-law firms based on your education or the firm you are currently with. While it sucks, the higher up the food chain you go the more factors like where you went to school, how well you did in school, and/or the reputation of the firm you are currently with matter.

As far as specific recommendations, I have worked with recruiters in two different markets and had two good experiences and a bunch of lousy ones. Let me know what market you're in and I can try to point you in the right direction.

Good luck!

Reply
bingojackson (Aug 30, 2016 - 3:30 pm)

not OP but if you have an recs for NYC I'd love to hear them

Reply
muaddib (Aug 31, 2016 - 5:59 pm)

I'm looking in LA and it seems like the market is just super dominated by BCG search here.

Interesting comment re "positions don't come up" this time of year. Is that because the firms are focused on doing OCI? I had a recruiter say that to me as well, but I honestly never know whether I should believe anything they tell me.

Waiting for the follow up from firms has been maddening so far. I did average at a top 20 school--don't know how different types of firms would perceive this. But you are right, I am not getting the response I am looking for...

I've had two interviews that went almost absurdly well. Good chemistry with the interviewers; long chats that went well over an hour; one guy said "you are an extremely impressive candidate"; another interviewer said "I think you would fit in very well here"... No response from either firm a month later... No idea what's going wrong.

Reply
bingojackson (Sep 1, 2016 - 12:01 pm)

while I think there's some value in being persistent and even a bit pushy (without being annoying, it's a fine line), everyone I've spoken to has told me that a job search, from start to finish, will likely take ~6 months, even if you're using a recruiter.

Reply
muaddib (Sep 1, 2016 - 3:17 pm)

Uhg. I was expecting three months... Time to buckle up I guess.

Reply
pauperesq (Sep 1, 2016 - 3:59 pm)

Although I'm sure there are several reasons why jobs don't open up this time of year, I believe the primary reason is no one wants to leave before receiving their year-end bonus.

Reply
Post a message in this thread